Homemade Pies and Custom Treats for Every Celebration
Each Order Prepared and Decorated with Care.
Sweet treats made to order for birthdays, baby showers, weddings, graduations, school events, and every celebration in between. From edible image sugar cookies and cake pops to dipped treats, cakesicles, strawberries, and our signature individual pies, we're here to help make your event a little sweeter.
Featured Creations
Discover some of our favorite treats, handcrafted and customized for your celebration.
Hand Dipped Cake Pops
Rich cake in the perfect bite-sized treat. Our Cake Pops are dipped in smooth candy coating and decorated especially for your celebration. (Not all flavors shown) From simple coordinating colors and sprinkles to custom edible images featuring photos, logos, names, or themed artwork, we can create a look that fits your event perfectly. Want less? Just call or message us! Edible Images are $5.00 extra per dozen
Made From Scratch Apple Pie
A classic comfort favorite in the perfect personal size. Our 5-inch Apple Pie is filled with sweet, warmly spiced apples and baked in a flaky homemade crust. Just right for gifting, gatherings, or enjoying all to yourself. Perfect for: 🎂 Birthdays 🎉 Parties & Celebrations 👶 Baby Showers 💍 Weddings 🏡 Family Gatherings 🎁 Host & Teacher Gifts ✔ Handcrafted in Fishers, Indiana ✔ Freshly baked to order ✔ Free delivery within 10 miles ✔ Pickup by appointment ✔ Additional delivery available for a fee
Made From Scratch Peach Pie
Sweet, cozy, and made for peach lovers. Our 5-inch Peach Pie features a delicious peach filling tucked inside our flaky homemade crust for a personal-sized take on a classic favorite. Perfect for: 🎂 Birthdays 🎉 Parties & Celebrations 👶 Baby Showers 💍 Weddings 🏡 Family Gatherings 🎁 Host & Teacher Gifts ✔ Handcrafted in Fishers, Indiana ✔ Freshly baked to order ✔ Free delivery within 10 miles ✔ Pickup by appointment ✔ Additional delivery available for a fee
Made From Scratch Pecan Pie
Rich, sweet, and packed with classic pecan pie flavor. Our 5-inch Pecan Pie combines a gooey, indulgent filling with plenty of pecans and our flaky homemade crust. A little pie that delivers a lot of old-fashioned dessert goodness. Perfect for: 🎂 Birthdays 🎉 Parties & Celebrations 👶 Baby Showers 💍 Weddings 🏡 Family Gatherings 🎁 Host & Teacher Gifts ✔ Handcrafted in Fishers, Indiana ✔ Freshly baked to order ✔ Free delivery within 10 miles ✔ Pickup by appointment ✔ Additional delivery available for a fee
Made From Scratch Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
A sweet-tart classic made with strawberries and rhubarb in our homemade pie crust. The bright strawberry flavor balances the tangy rhubarb for a fresh, old-fashioned fruit pie that’s perfect for spring, summer, or anytime you want something a little different.
Personalized Edible Image Sugar Cookies
Turn a favorite photo, logo, or design into something you can eat! Our sugar cookies are finished with smooth icing and topped with vibrant edible images created especially for your celebration. Use your own photo or artwork, or tell us your theme and let us help create a design. Perfect for birthdays, graduations, school and sports events, business logos, showers, weddings, memorials, family celebrations, and anywhere you want the dessert to feel truly personal.
Why Choose Us
Quality, trust, and community at the heart of everything
About Us!
Bite Sized Smiles Co. is a family owned business in Fishers, Indiana, built around one simple idea—every celebration deserves something special.
We love creating handcrafted treats that bring people together, whether it's a birthday, baby shower, graduation, wedding, school event, holiday, or just because. From edible image sugar cookies and cake pops to dipped favorites and our signature individual pies, every order is made fresh and customized with care.
Because at Bite Sized Smiles Co., it's never just dessert—it's part of someone's celebration.
Get first access to drops, pre-orders, and announcements
Enter your email to unlock the full experience with Bite Sized Smiles Co. — track orders, get notifications, and more.
Benefits:
- Track orders
- Live chat with Bite Sized Smiles Co.
- Customize notifications
- Benefit from loyalty rewards